Sometimes The Best Isn't The Brightest

Sometimes the Best Isn’t the Brightest – Screen Carefully and Methodically

If you ask them casually, most hiring managers and HR professionals will probably tell you they want to fill their organizations with the smartest people they can find. We all know, though, that there are times when the best person isn’t necessarily the brightest. Successful hiring is often not so much about finding the best person as it is about finding the best fit. To draw a parallel, if you’re going hiking, it’s wise to pick a pair of sturdy boots and leave behind the sequined Gucci pumps, even if they do look darling with that new backpack. We need to see beyond the glitter and consider the path ahead.

In the current economy, it’s common to get hundreds or even thousands of applications for a single position. Among them, you’ll almost always find a few members of the tall forehead brigade, brows bulging with education and intellect. Depending on the position for which you’re hiring, they might belong

right at the top of your list, or they may be the first people you should eliminate. It’s a decision that shouldn’t be made lightly, however. Few veterans of the hiring process would deny there are usually some candidates who are clearly over-qualified for a position, not just in terms of education and experience, but in terms of sheer intelligence. This affects not only their immediate suitability, but also whether they’re likely to stay in the job without getting bored, and whether they’re likely to disrupt your existing environment while they’re there.

Ideally, hiring is about building a team, not just collecting individuals. You need to think long-term and consider how any new piece will fit into the existing whole. Here are a few points to ponder while you’re mulling over all those resumés and trying to weed out candidates based on one criterion, such as intelligence, alone.

To obtain the full article and hrdownloads templates click here.  You must be a member view this portion of the article.  To become an OACC member contact Dena Stuart at



CCO Members

Membership in CCO can help you and your staff understand the facts, keep informed and learn how to participate in the establishment of outcomes.

If you are not a member please apply for membership to get full access to our website and many other benefits.

news events stories


Evaluation of the Second Career Program

In 2015, the Ministry of Advanced Education and Skills Development (MAESD) contracted an evaluation of the Second Career program to assess the long-term evidence on its use and effectiveness for displaced workers in Ontario. The ministry has since published the report this month.
Read More

Report on police oversight bodies highlights potential training opportunities

The report offers three recommendations pertaining to the training of police oversight bodies and gives reference to potential training opportunities, which may prove relevant to career colleges, and those offering Police Foundations training in particular.
Read More

Conference Program | June 14-16

Interested in attending our conference this June? Don't miss out on the sessions that matter to you and your college. Now you can browse our preliminary program online, check out our program at a glance, and plan your trip in advance!
Read More

See all news

Upcoming Events

CCO Annual Conference
Date 6/14/2017

See all events


CCO Awards 2016: Excellence in Teaching

Meet the recipient of the CCO Award for Excellence in Teaching, Bruce Caine.
Read More

CCO Awards 2016: Outstanding Graduate in Services

Meet the Award Recipient for this year's CCO Award for Outstanding Graduate in the Services category, Lionel Martins.
Read More

CCO Awards 2016: Outstanding Graduate in Health Services

Meet the Award Recipient for this year's CCO Award for Outstanding Graduate in the Health Services category, Jacob Teschke.
Read More

See all stories